Amarjeet Sohi, Edmonton Ward 12 Councillor

Train whistling at the 38 Avenue CN railway crossing

Feb
07
2012

 

Lately a number of residents have written to me with concerns about noise from trains whistling at the railway crossing in the Maple Neighbourhood, around 38 Avenue and east of 17 Street. I've noticed more whistling lately at this location, too. I want to provide a bit of information about why this is the case, and what the City has done to address the issue. 

A train is required to sound its engine whistle a quarter-mile before public crossings. This is done as a safety measure, to alert drivers and pedestrians of approaching trains. This is federally regulated under Canada's Railway Safety Act

Given this, railway crossings would ideally be situated far from residential areas, to reduce noise disturbance and its effects on quality of life. However, it is the case that some residential areas exist near, and are growing around, active railways. 

Municipalities can initiate a request for an anti-whistling agreement in a given location -- and Edmonton has made this request on behalf of residents for the Maple railway crossing. First, the City assesses the location for eligibility (whistling cannot be stopped at all railway crossings). The railway then reviews the City's information and makes its own assessment, possibly requiring additional warning systems (e.g., bells, lights, gates) to be installed prior to supporting the anti-whistling agreement. The City pays for additional warning systems if they're needed. Once the railway is satisfied with these provisions, they forward the City's application to Transport Canada for ultimate approval. 

My Council colleages and I recently moved this process forward, asking the City to pursue an Anti-Whistle Agreement. At this point, the City has completed its steps to get the process going, and we are waiting for approval from the railway and, eventually, from Transport Canada. As a result, I hope to see noise reduced at this crossing over the coming months. 

Here is some background information from CN on train whistling, as well as a useful pamphlet on why trains whistle in the first place.

Comments about "Train whistling at the 38 Avenue CN railway crossing"

Review entry | Have your say

the noise does travel quite a ways, we have lived in Jackson Heights, and the whistles were still heard.I think the sound of a whistle in the distance is nice, but not if you have to hear it 8, 10 , 12 times per day!

Posted by DARYL JAMIESON on 02/17 at 05:44 PM

I introduce a Law student in Islamic University of Indonesia Yogyakarta


thanks for sharing
nice post smile

Posted by UII Official on 04/17 at 08:26 PM

 

Have your say

Review entry | Review comments

Comments are moderated for civility. Fields marked with * are required before the moderator can approve the comments.

* Your name:

* Your email address:

Location:

* Your comments:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Privacy Policy: We respect your privacy. We will not forward your personal information to any other organization except as required by law, and will use your e-mail address only to respond to your comments. We reserve the right to edit and remove comments for length, clarity and/or if they are illegal or inappropriate. Your email address is never shown to visitors to sohi.ca.